The claim specifies a precise outcome (3-1 victory, Open Cup, Sports Illustrated Stadium, last eight) that is not corroborated by multiple independent sources. While multiple sources mention the teams and the stadium, none confirm the specific match result or the exact tournament stage described in the claim.

The claim makes specific historical claims about aggregate scores (8-0 in last three Open Cup matchups) and specific elimination years (2023 and 2024). No independent sources corroborate these specific numerical records or the sequence of eliminations in the Leagues Cup and MLS Playoffs.

The claim names three specific players (Kai Trewin, Raul Gustavo, Thiago Martins) who scored goals and mentions the resulting chants. While multiple sources list these players in connection with NYCFC, no independent source confirms that all three scored goals on the same Wednesday, nor does any source confirm the specific chants.

The claim states that Julian Hall scored his ninth goal of the season in all competitions during the Red Bulls' loss. While multiple sources confirm Julian Hall scored and was involved in the game, none independently confirm that this specific goal was his ninth of the season in all competitions.

The claim makes two distinct points: Poland not qualifying for the World Cup, and Julian Hall being considered for the USA squad. While web search results confirm information about Poland and Julian Hall's background, no independent sources corroborate the specific combination of these facts or the 'long-shot candidate' status for the USA squad.

The claim specifies a future date (May 16) for a regular-season rematch. While one web search result mentions a rematch date, no other independent source corroborates this specific date, making it a single-source claim.