Meta and YouTube found liable in social media addiction trial
Original article: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c747x7gz249o
Fact-Check Results
“Jurors found that Meta, which owns Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp, and Google, owner of YouTube, intentionally built addictive social media platforms that harmed the 20-year old's mental health.”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive to verify or refute claims about Meta, Google, and Kaley's mental health.
“The woman, known as Kaley, was awarded $6m (£4.5m) in damages, a result likely to have implications for hundreds of similar cases now winding their way through US courts.”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive to confirm Kaley's damages award amount or details.
“Meta and Google said they disagreed with the verdict and intended to appeal”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive about Meta and Google's intent to appeal the verdict.
“Meta said: 'Teen mental health is profoundly complex and cannot be linked to a single app.'”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive to verify Meta's statement about teen mental health.
“Google said: 'This case misunderstands YouTube, which is a responsibly built streaming platform, not a social media site.'”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive about Google's classification of YouTube as a streaming platform.
“The jury found that Kaley should receive $3m in compensatory damages and an additional $3m punitive damages, because they determined Meta and Google 'acted with malice, oppression, or fraud' in the way the companies operated their platforms.”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive to confirm jury's findings about malice or fraud.
“Meta will be expected to shoulder 70% of Kaley's damages award, with Google the remaining 30%.”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive about the allocation of damages between Meta and Google.
“Parents of other children, who are not part of Kaley's lawsuit but claim they also were harmed by social media, were outside the courthouse on Wednesday, as they had been many days throughout the five-week trial.”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive about parents' presence outside the courthouse.
“The LA verdict came a day after a jury in New Mexico found Meta liable for the way in which its platforms endangered children and exposed them to sexually explicit material and contact with sexual predators.”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive about New Mexico jury's findings against Meta.
“Australia has imposed restrictions for children to stop or limit their use of social media. The UK is currently running a pilot programme to see how a ban of social media for people aged under 16 may work.”
❓
INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
— No evidence in archive about Australia's restrictions or UK's pilot program.
“Kaley said she was 10 years old when she started having feelings of anxiety and depression, disorders for which she would be diagnosed years later by a therapist.”
❓
PENDING
“A separate case against Meta and other social media platforms over their alleged harms to children is poised to begin in June in California federal court.”
❓
PENDING
“Meta's growth goals were aimed at getting young people to use its platforms, Kaley's lawyers said.”
❓
PENDING
“Kaley said she started using Instagram aged nine and YouTube aged six, and encountered no attempts to block her because of her age.”
❓
PENDING
“Snap and TikTok were also initially defendants, but both companies reached undisclosed settlements with Kaley prior to trial.”
❓
PENDING
“Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram, denied that 16 hours of daily use was evidence of an addiction.”
❓
PENDING
“Her lawyers argued that features of Instagram, like infinite scroll, were designed to be addictive.”
❓
PENDING
“Kaley has since been diagnosed with body dysmorphia, a condition which causes people to worry excessively about their physical appearance and prevents them from seeing themselves as others do.”
❓
PENDING
“Mark Zuckerberg, Meta's chairman and chief executive, relied on his company's longstanding policy of not allowing users under the age of 13 on any of its platforms.”
❓
PENDING